20CV19618: Difference between revisions

From Raindrop Works Court Records
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 3: Line 3:


=== Initial Complaint ===
=== Initial Complaint ===
[[Wikipedia:Andy Ngo|Andy Ngo]], former writer for Vanguard and Quillette, currently works as an Editor at Large for Post Millennial, a Canadian media organization. He filed a case alleging assault, battery, intentional infliction of emotional distress, as well as claims against Oregon's RICO statutes, requesting $900,000 in damages. The original complaint named Rose City Antifa, Benjamin Bolen, John Hacker, Katherine Belyea, Joseph Evans, Madison Allen and 50 Doe defendants. In the introduction, he claimed that these parties were coordinating to harass, stalk and intimidate him, and that Antifa was declared a 'domestic terrorist group' by the US government (Politico's reporting on this claim suggests that while the federal government did make this determination in 2016, it appears that is was a direct response to increasing threats of right wing extremism, as well as, at worst, it's seen as a disorganized group of cells that sometimes coordinate with each other<ref>https://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/01/antifa-charlottesville-violence-fbi-242235</ref>.) The first factual allegation made in this complaint references two op-eds that written to The Hill<ref>https://thehill-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/500764-why-its-likely-to-be-antifa-not-neo-nazis-behind-the-anarchy-in-america/amp/</ref> and Washington Examiner<ref>https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/editorials/trump-is-right-antifa-are-terrorists-they-always-were</ref> in his claims that Antifa calls for insurrectionary anarchy to overthrow the government. (While The Hill is generally leased biased and mostly factual in it's reporting, Media Bias does not list the op-ed author, James Casey, as one of it's normal opinion writers<ref>https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-hill/</ref>. Mr. Casey's bio indicates he was a career law enforcement officer, with a specialty in militia, neo-Nazi and anarchist groups. Washington Examiner, however, is rated as as significant right leaning in their content and editorials, with only mixed factual reporting<ref>https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/washington-examiner/</ref>. Their op-ed is attributed to the outlet itself, with no individual writer taking credit.
[[Wikipedia:Andy Ngo|Andy Ngo]], former writer for Vanguard and Quillette, currently works as an Editor at Large for Post Millennial, a Canadian media organization. He filed a case alleging assault, battery, intentional infliction of emotional distress, as well as claims against Oregon's RICO statutes, requesting $900,000 in damages. The original complaint named Rose City Antifa, Benjamin Bolen, John Hacker, Katherine Belyea, Joseph Evans, Madison Allen and 50 Doe defendants. In the introduction, he claimed that these parties were coordinating to harass, stalk and intimidate him, and that Antifa was declared a 'domestic terrorist group' by the US government (Politico's reporting on this claim suggests that while the federal government did make this determination in 2016, it appears that is was a direct response to increasing threats of right wing extremism, as well as, at worst, it's seen as a disorganized group of cells that sometimes coordinate with each other<ref>https://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/01/antifa-charlottesville-violence-fbi-242235</ref>.) The first factual allegation made in this complaint references two op-eds that written to The Hill<ref name=":3">https://thehill-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/500764-why-its-likely-to-be-antifa-not-neo-nazis-behind-the-anarchy-in-america/amp/</ref> and Washington Examiner<ref>https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/editorials/trump-is-right-antifa-are-terrorists-they-always-were</ref> in his claims that Antifa calls for insurrectionary anarchy to overthrow the government. (While The Hill is generally leased biased and mostly factual in it's reporting, Media Bias does not list the op-ed author, James Casey, as one of it's normal opinion writers<ref>https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-hill/</ref>. Mr. Casey's bio indicates he was a career law enforcement officer, with a specialty in militia, neo-Nazi and anarchist groups. Washington Examiner, however, is rated as as significant right leaning in their content and editorials, with only mixed factual reporting<ref>https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/washington-examiner/</ref>. Their op-ed is attributed to the outlet itself, with no individual writer taking credit.


==== May 1, 2019 ====
==== May 1, 2019 ====
Line 27: Line 27:
On September 21st, 2020, Benjamin Bolen, who Mr. Ngo claimed 'rabbit punched' him in the stomach on May 1st, 2019, files a motion asking to be stricken from the case, claiming that he never punched Mr. Ngo, and that the photo that Mr. Ngo used to identify him in the complaint is a completely different person. He also raised objections that the complaint was overly broad, not showing a good connection between any of the parties or dates involved, and that the real motivation for the lawsuit was to punish others for their political ideology.
On September 21st, 2020, Benjamin Bolen, who Mr. Ngo claimed 'rabbit punched' him in the stomach on May 1st, 2019, files a motion asking to be stricken from the case, claiming that he never punched Mr. Ngo, and that the photo that Mr. Ngo used to identify him in the complaint is a completely different person. He also raised objections that the complaint was overly broad, not showing a good connection between any of the parties or dates involved, and that the real motivation for the lawsuit was to punish others for their political ideology.


In November 2020, Judge Kathleen Daily denied the motion, stating that since this was essentially an anti-SLAPP motion, violence alleged against another person is not protected speech under the First Amendment, and a case of mistaken identity is not sufficient reason by itself to strike the allegations from the complaint. It was a defense that could be made at trial. Mr. Bolen appealed the case to the appellate court, who upheld the judge's decision.
In November 2020, Judge Kathleen Daily denied the motion, stating that since this was essentially an anti-SLAPP motion, violence alleged against another person is not protected speech under the First Amendment, and as the alleged punch was the cause of the lawsuit against Bolen, it was that punch that would have to be seen as protected speech before the legal analysis could continue. It was a defense that could be made at trial. Mr. Bolen appealed the case to the appellate court (under case A175559), who upheld the judge's decision.


During the flurry of motions and cross-motions dealing with the strike, Mr. Ngo claimed that he was attacked at 2:45pm on May 1st, had no injuries at the time and had been experiencing pain immediately after being punched and sought medical treatment. However, the brawl at Cider Riot! was early in the evening and it's uncertain if he would have sought treatment before or after the alleged pepper there.
During the flurry of motions and cross-motions dealing with the strike, Mr. Ngo claimed that he was attacked at 2:45pm on May 1st, had no injuries at the time and had been experiencing pain immediately after being punched and sought medical treatment. However, the brawl at Cider Riot! was early in the evening and it's uncertain if he would have sought treatment before or after the alleged pepper there. His lawyer also claimed that the declarations by Bolen and another witness were full of unverifiable claims or outright fabrications. Many of the filings by Mr. Ngo's lawyers relink the same Hill<ref name=":3" /> editorial vilifying Antifa as a group.
 
By the end of October, the court docket is filled with a flurry of motions to strike, cross motions to strike, responses to the cross motion to strike, and responses to the responses to cross motion to strike, which, while not entirely uncommon in complex litigation, does make for confusing reading.


== Parties ==
== Parties ==
Line 69: Line 71:
|Defendant
|Defendant
|Active
|Active
|}
== Media ==
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!Date
!Event
!FTR Audio
!MP3
|-
|11/16/2020
|Hearing
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201119-Hearing-FTR.zip ZIP]<ref>{{FTR}}</ref>
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201119-Hearing-MP3.mp3 MP3]
|}
|}


Line 199: Line 215:
|Motion - Strike
|Motion - Strike
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Cross-Motion-to-Strike.pdf Cross motion from Ngo to strike 9/21 Declarations]
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Cross-Motion-to-Strike.pdf Cross motion from Ngo to strike 9/21 Declarations]
|-
|10/5/2020
|Memorandum - Support Motion
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Memorandum-of-Law.pdf Memorandum of Law]
|-
|-
|10/5/2020
|10/5/2020
Line 204: Line 224:
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Declaration.pdf Andy Ngo opposition to Bolen's Motion]
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Declaration.pdf Andy Ngo opposition to Bolen's Motion]
|-
|-
|10/5/2020
|Memorandum - Opposing Motion
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201005-Memorandum.pdf Andy Ngo opposition to Bolen's 9/21 motion]
|-
|10/21/2020
|Order
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/20CV19618-20201021-Order-1.pdf Appointing Judge Kathleen Daily as motions judge]
|-
|10/21/2020
|Notice
|Appointment of Judge
|-
|10/15/2020
|Reply
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201015-Reply.pdf Bolen in support of anti-SLAPP motion]
|-
|10/15/2020
|Response
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201015-Response.pdf Bolen response to Ngo's motion to strike declarations]
|-
|10/22/2020
|Reply
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20CV19618-20201022-Reply.pdf Ngo response in support of his 10/5 motion]
|-
|11/13/2020
|Motion - Allow Service by Mail
|Newspaper publication to serve Madison Allen and Joseph Evans<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":4">In this instance, there is information indicating that the defendants have no connection with the addresses in the filings, so they are withheld to protect non-parties to the case.</ref>
|-
|11/13/2020
|Declaration
|Carole Caldwell, support of Alternative Service motion<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":4" />
|-
|11/13/2020
|Order - Proposed
|For allowing alternative service<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":4" />
|-
|11/19/2020
|Hearing - Motion
|Motion to Strike
|-
|12/15/2020
|Opinion
|[https://raindrop.works/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/20CV19618-20201215-Order-on-Motions-to-Strike.pdf Order - Defendant Motion to Strike denied, Plantiff granted in part and denied in part]
|-
|12/23/2020
|Order
|[https://cdn.raindrop.works/2023/08/06201049/20CV19618-20201223-Order.pdf Service by Publication (signed order of the 11/13/2020 proposed order)]
|}
=== Q1 2021 ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!Date
!Filing
!Information/Documents
|-
|3/8/2023
|Assignment - Transcriber
|
|
|
|-
|
|3/8/2023
|Certificate
|[https://cdn.raindrop.works/2023/08/06202109/20CV19618-20210308-Certificate.pdf Certificate of Notice to Court Reporter/Transcriber]
|-
|3/8/2023
|Affidavit/Declaration - Publication
|Proof of alternative service for Madison Allen<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":4" />
|-
|3/8/2023
|Affidavit/Declaration - Publication
|Proof of alternative service for Joseph Evans<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":4" />
|-
|3/9/2023
|Notice - Appeal
|[https://cdn.raindrop.works/2023/08/06202631/20CV19618-20210309-Notice.pdf Bolen's appeal of 12/15/2020 order]
|-
|3/10/2021
|Notice
|Rule 7 - 91 Day
|}
|}

Revision as of 03:45, 7 August 2023

Andyway Ongay vsay. Oseray Itycay Antifaway etway alway

Isthay asecay isway a onglay indingway andway atway imestay onfusingcay asecay eaturingfay a oadbray arietyvay ofway allegationsway againstway a umbernay ofway individualsway andway organizationsway, ithway eventsway artingstay inway 2019 orway earlierway. Ueday otay urrentcay ediamay orderway ulesray, uchmay accurateway informationway omfray ethay actualway ialtray isway ardhay otay indfay andway isthay aymay ogay oughthray ignificantsay evisionsray asway a esultray.

Initialway Omplaintcay

Andyway Ongay, ormerfay iterwray orfay Anguardvay andway Illettequay, urrentlycay orksway asway anway Editorway atway Argelay orfay Ostpay Illennialmay, a Anadiancay ediamay organizationway. Ehay iledfay a asecay allegingway assaultway, atterybay, intentionalway inflictionway ofway emotionalway istressday, asway ellway asway aimsclay againstway Oregon'sway RICO atutesstay, equestingray $900,000 inway amagesday. Ethay originalway omplaintcay amednay Oseray Itycay Antifaway, Enjaminbay Olenbay, Ohnjay Ackerhay, Atherinekay Elyeabay, Osephjay Evansway, Adisonmay Allenway andway 50 Oeday efendantsday. Inway ethay introductionway, ehay aimedclay atthay esethay artiespay ereway oordinatingcay otay arasshay, alkstay andway intimidateway imhay, andway atthay Antifaway asway eclaredday a 'omesticday erroristtay oup'gray ybay ethay US overnmentgay (Olitico'spay eportingray onway isthay aimclay uggestssay atthay ilewhay ethay ederalfay overnmentgay idday akemay isthay eterminationday inway 2016, itway appearsway atthay isway asway a irectday esponseray otay increasingway eatsthray ofway ightray ingway extremismway, asway ellway asway, atway orstway, it'sway eensay asway a isorganizedday oupgray ofway ellscay atthay ometimessay oordinatecay ithway eachway otherway[1].) Ethay irstfay actualfay allegationway ademay inway isthay omplaintcay eferencesray otway opway-edsway atthay ittenwray otay Ethay Illhay[2] andway Ashingtonway Examinerway[3] inway ishay aimsclay atthay Antifaway allscay orfay insurrectionaryway anarchyway otay overthrowway ethay overnmentgay. (Ilewhay Ethay Illhay isway enerallygay easedlay iasedbay andway ostlymay actualfay inway it'sway eportingray, Ediamay Iasbay oesday otnay istlay ethay opway-edway authorway, Amesjay Aseycay, asway oneway ofway it'sway ormalnay opinionway iterswray[4]. mray. Asey'scay iobay indicatesway ehay asway a areercay awlay enforcementway officerway, ithway a ecialtyspay inway ilitiamay, eonay-Azinay andway anarchistway oupsgray. Ashingtonway Examinerway, oweverhay, isway atedray asway asway ignificantsay ightray eaninglay inway eirthay ontentcay andway editorialsway, ithway onlyway ixedmay actualfay eportingray[5]. Eirthay opway-edway isway attributedway otay ethay outletway itselfway, ithway onay individualway iterwray akingtay editcray.

Aymay 1, 2019

Ethay irstfay individualway aimclay atthay isway ademay isway atthay Ohnjay Olenbay unchedpay mray. Ongay inway ethay abdomenway atway anway ICE otestpray onway Aymay Ayday 2019. Aterlay atthay ayday, mray. Ongay entway otay Idercay Iotray!, a incesay osedclay arbay otay ocumentday a otestpray ybay Atriotpay Ayerpray ofway a atheringgay ofway eftistslay individualsway afterway eirthay annedplay otestspray ereway oneday orfay ethay ayday. mray. Ongay otednay atthay ethay arbay asway incesay osedclay afterway ethay ithay-andway-unray illingkay ofway antiway ascistfay Eansay Ealiherkay, a asecay atthay asway illstay openway atway ethay imetay ofway ethay omplaintcay (incesay enthay, Ortlandpay Olicepay arrestedway ethay imarypray uspectsay inway Augustway ofway 2022, afterway OPB eportedray atthay ecordsray owedshay PPB urposefullypay owslay alkedway ethay investigationway, ossiblypay orfay ideologicalway easonsray[6].) mray. Ongay asway allegedlyway acedmay ybay a Oeday efendantday andway edflay ethay enescay ueday otay otnay eelingfay afesay. Anymay ofway esethay etailsday ereway overedcay inway ethay ubsequentsay iotray argeschay againstway a arietyvay ofway embersmay ofway Atriotpay Ayerpray. Omesay embersmay ooktay eaplay ealsday, omesay ereway oundfay uiltygay, andway omesay asescay ereway ismissedday ybay ethay udgejay.

Aymay 7, 2019

Ethay econdsay incidentway, a eekway aterlay, ereway allegationsway againstway Ohnjay Ackerhay orfay owingthray anway 'unknownway iquid'lay ontoway mray. O'sngay eadhay andway ealingstay ishay onephay enwhay mray. Ongay attemptedway otay ecordray imhay. Everalsay earsyay aterlay, mray. Ackerhay asway argedchay ithway elonyfay eftthay inway ethay asecay, andway inway ethay asecay, ethay 'unknownway iquid'lay urnedtay outway otay ebay aterway, andway ethay 'eft'thay ofway ethay onephay asway anway unplannedway actionway ueday otay mray. Ackerhay otnay eelingfay afesay eingbay ilmedfay ybay mray. Ongay, oublyday osay inway a aceplay atthay adhay a 'onay amera'cay olicypay inway aceplay. Ortlyshay afterway mray. Ackerhay ooktay ethay onephay, ehay andedhay itway otay ymgay affstay owhay eturnedray itway otay mray. Ongay ithway onay urtherfay incidentway. Inway ethay iminalcray ialtray, mray. Ongay admittedway atthay ethay onlyway amageday atthay ayday asway a ackcray otay ishay onephay asecay (atthay ehay ouldn'tcay identifyway asedbay onway olicepay otosphay ofway ethay asecay). Ethay udgejay oundfay mray. Ackerhay innocentway ofway ethay argechay inway ethay iminalcray asecay (itway isway orthway otingnay ethay urdenbay ofway oofpray isway owerlay inway ivilcay asescay anthay iminalcray asescay), utbay adhay ongstray ordsway orfay othbay artiespay aboutway ethay incidentway andway eirthay actionsway.

Unejay 29, 2019

Onway isthay ayday mray. Ongay arguablyway ecamebay orldway amousfay orfay ethay 'ilkshakemay incident'way. Atway a otestpray erewhay anotherway organizationway, OppayObmay, asway andinghay outway eganvay ilkshakesmay, a umbernay ofway eoplepay ewthray eirthay ilkshakesmay atway mray. Ongay. Ehay allegedway Atherinekay Elyeabay asway oneway uchsay individualway. Ortlandpay Olicepay adhay issuedway a arningway onway eirthay Ittertway accountway atthay ethay ilkshakesmay aymay avehay ontainedcay ickquay-yingdray oncretecay[7]. Iorpray investigativeway eportingray owedshay atthay ethay evidenceway asicallybay amecay omfray owhay oneway olicepay officersway oughtthay ethay inksdray elledsmay ikelay etway oncretecay, evenway oughthay onay oneway inkingdray emthay ufferedsay illway effectsway[8]. mray. Ongay aterlay aimsclay ehay asway 'obbedmay andway oodied'blay ybay a oupgray ofway Oseray Itycay Antifaway embersmay, istedlay asway Oesday 21-43 andway ecificallyspay amingnay Osephjay Evansway andway Adisonmay Allenway asway assailantsway.

Afterway eportingray ethay attackway otay olicepay atway ethay Entralcay Ecinctpray, ehay entway otay OHSU, erewhay ehay allegedway ehay asway iagnosedday ithway a 'ubarachnoidsay ainbray emorrhagehay[9] andway ospitalizedhay overnight'way (inway ethay ubsequentsay iminalcray ialtray againstway mray. Ackerhay, mray. Ongay uggestedsay, andway agreedway ithway ethay efense'sday estionquay, atthay ehay ufferedsay ainbray amageday inway ethay incidentway). Everalsay aysday aterlay a ideovay asway ostedpay otay ethay Oxfay Ewsnay OuyayUbetay annelchay ofway anway interviewway ehay avegay emthay afterway ethay attackway[10].

Octoberway 31, 2019

Asway artpay ofway a otestpray/ankpray onway Alloweenhay, ixsay eoplepay earingway asksmay ofway mray. O'sngay acefay oodstay outsideway ishay omehay, angingbay onway indowsway andway yingtray otay openway ethay oorday andlehay. Isthay oldtay mray. Ongay atthay ishay ersonalpay informationway adhay eenbay oundfay outway andway istributedday amongway otherway eoplepay, andway atthay uchsay oxxingday ausedcay imhay otay earfay orfay ethay afetysay ofway imhay andway ishay amilyfay.

Afterway ayinglay outway ethay aimsclay orfay amageday, ehay askedway orfay a udgementjay 'exceedingway $300,000, ebledtray otay $900,000' (asway artpay ofway ethay Oregonway RICO atutesstay) asway ellway asway attorneyway eesfay andway ostscay, epray-interestway udgementjay, andway injunctiveway eliefray eventingpray ethay Efendantsday omfray 'arassinghay, eateningthray, arming'hay mray. Ongay.

Ervicesay ifficultiesday

Almostway immediatelyway ethay asecay eganbay unningray intoway oblemspray, asway ybay ethay endway ofway Augustway onlyway otway artiespay ereway actuallyway ervedsay, ithway eoplepay otnay amednay inway ethay asecay ettinggay ervedsay (esumablypray inway anway attemptway otay ervesay Oseray Itycay Antifaway) andway ifficultiesday indingfay otherway efendantsday otay ovidepray ervicesay. Omfray Augustway 2020 otay Archmay ofway 2021 mray. Ongay orkedway ithway ethay ourtscay otay attemptway otay ervesay efendantsday owhay ehay allegedway adhay edflay ethay atestay andway/orway ereway uckingday ocesspray erverssay otay avoidway ervicesay. Inway Eptembersay 3, 2020 ilingsfay, ethay ocesspray erversay atedstay atthay othbay ereway attemptingway otay alsoway evadeway unrelatedway ourtcay actionsway andway enchbay arrantsway, andway atway eastlay oneway asway attemptingway ervicesay inway Oisebay, Idahoway.

Enjaminbay Olenbay attemptsway otay ancelcay asecay againstway imhay

Onway Eptembersay 21stay, 2020, Enjaminbay Olenbay, owhay mray. Ongay aimedclay 'abbitray unched'pay imhay inway ethay omachstay onway Aymay 1stay, 2019, ilesfay a otionmay askingway otay ebay ickenstray omfray ethay asecay, aimingclay atthay ehay evernay unchedpay mray. Ongay, andway atthay ethay otophay atthay mray. Ongay usedway otay identifyway imhay inway ethay omplaintcay isway a ompletelycay ifferentday ersonpay. Ehay alsoway aisedray objectionsway atthay ethay omplaintcay asway overlyway oadbray, otnay owingshay a oodgay onnectioncay etweenbay anyway ofway ethay artiespay orway atesday involvedway, andway atthay ethay ealray otivationmay orfay ethay awsuitlay asway otay unishpay othersway orfay eirthay oliticalpay ideologyway.

Inway Ovembernay 2020, Udgejay Athleenkay Ailyday eniedday ethay otionmay, atingstay atthay incesay isthay asway essentiallyway anway antiway-SLAPP otionmay, iolencevay allegedway againstway anotherway ersonpay isway otnay otectedpray eechspay underway ethay Irstfay Amendmentway, andway asway ethay allegedway unchpay asway ethay ausecay ofway ethay awsuitlay againstway Olenbay, itway asway atthay unchpay atthay ouldway avehay otay ebay eensay asway otectedpray eechspay eforebay ethay egallay analysisway ouldcay ontinuecay. Itway asway a efenseday atthay ouldcay ebay ademay atway ialtray. mray. Olenbay appealedway ethay asecay otay ethay appellateway ourtcay (underway asecay A175559), owhay upheldway ethay udge'sjay ecisionday.

Uringday ethay urryflay ofway otionsmay andway osscray-otionsmay ealingday ithway ethay ikestray, mray. Ongay aimedclay atthay ehay asway attackedway atway 2:45pmay onway Aymay 1stay, adhay onay injuriesway atway ethay imetay andway adhay eenbay experiencingway ainpay immediatelyway afterway eingbay unchedpay andway oughtsay edicalmay eatmenttray. Oweverhay, ethay awlbray atway Idercay Iotray! asway earlyway inway ethay eveningway andway it'sway uncertainway ifway ehay ouldway avehay oughtsay eatmenttray eforebay orway afterway ethay allegedway epperpay erethay. Ishay awyerlay alsoway aimedclay atthay ethay eclarationsday ybay Olenbay andway anotherway itnessway ereway ullfay ofway unverifiableway aimsclay orway outrightway abricationsfay. Anymay ofway ethay ilingsfay ybay mray. O'sngay awyerslay elinkray ethay amesay Illhay[2] editorialway ilifyingvay Antifaway asway a oupgray.

Ybay ethay endway ofway Octoberway, ethay ourtcay ocketday isway illedfay ithway a urryflay ofway otionsmay otay ikestray, osscray otionsmay otay ikestray, esponsesray otay ethay osscray otionmay otay ikestray, andway esponsesray otay ethay esponsesray otay osscray otionmay otay ikestray, ichwhay, ilewhay otnay entirelyway uncommonway inway omplexcay itigationlay, oesday akemay orfay onfusingcay eadingray.

Artiespay

Amenay Artypay Atusstay
Andyway Ongay Antiffplay Activeway
Oseray Itycay Antifaway Efendantday Ismissedday (Uleray 7 ismissalday)
Adisonmay Eelay Allenway Efendantday Ismissedday (Uleray 7 ismissalday)[11]
Enjaminbay Olenbay Efendantday Ismissedday (Asecay Ettledsay)
Atharinekay Elyeabay Efendantday Ismissedday (Uleray 7 ismissalday)[11]
Osephjay Evansway Efendantday Ismissedday (Uleray 7 ismissalday)[11]
Ohnjay Ackerhay Efendantday Activeway
Elizabethway Ichterray Efendantday Activeway

Ediamay

Ateday Eventway FTR Audioway MP3
11/16/2020 Earinghay ZIP[12] MP3

Ourtcay Ecordsray

Q2 2020

Ateday Ilingfay Informationway/Ocumentsday
6/4/2020 Omplaintcay [PDF]
6/23/2020 Otionmay Outway ofway Atestay Attorneyway
6/23/2020 Eclarationday Armeethay Illiondhay inway upportsay ofway opray ochay icevay
6/23/2020 Eclarationday Egorygray Ichaelmay inway upportsay ofway opray ochay icevay

Q3 2020

Ateday Ilingfay Informationway/Ocumentsday
7/8/2020 Orderway Antinggray Otionmay orfay Admissionway ofway Attorneyway opray ochay icevay Armeethay Illondhay
7/8/2020 Orderway Antinggray Otionmay orfay Admissionway ofway Attorneyway opray ochay icevay Egorygray Ichaelmay
8/18/2020 Oticenay
8/21/2020 Oofpray - Ervicesay - Ubstitutesay uponway Uliejay Acksonjay onnay-artypay[13][14]
8/21/2020 Oofpray - Ervicesay Atherinekay Elyeabay[13]
8/21/2020 Oofpray - Ervicesay Ohnjay Ackerhay[13]
8/21/2020 Affidavitway/Eclarationday - Ailingmay Ailedmay otay Enbay Olenbay[13]
8/26/2020 Oofpray - Ervicesay uponway Uislay Arquezmay onnay-artypay[13][14]
8/28/2020 Oticenay - Intentway Aketay Efaultday Ohnjay Ackerhay
8/28/2020 Oticenay - Intentway Aketay Efaultday Ohnjay Olenbay
8/28/2020 Oticenay - Intentway Aketay Atherinekay Elyeabay
9/1/2020 Oticenay - Ithdrawalway ofway Attorneyway Egorygray Ichaelmay orfay Andyway Ongay
9/3/2020 Otionmay - Ontinuancecay Unableway otay ervesay Osephjay Evansway[13]
9/3/2020 Otionmay - Ontinuancecay Unableway otay ervesay Adisonmay Allenway[13]
9/3/2020 Orderway - Oposedpray Ontinuancecay ueday otay ervicesay
9/11/2020 Oticenay - Epresentationray Orfay Ohnjay Ackerhay
9/16/2020 Orderway Uleray 7 Ervicesay Ostponementpay Antedgray (orfay Osephjay Evansway)
9/16/2020 Orderway Uleray 7 Ervicesay Ostponementpay Antedgray (orfay Adisonmay Allenway)
9/21/2020 Otionmay - Ikestray Olenbay, equestingray eingbay uckstray omfray ethay asecay.
9/21/2020 Eclarationday ofway Enjaminbay inway Upportsay ofway Ecialspay Otionmay otay Ikestray
9/21/2020 Eclarationday ofway Aneshay Urleybay inway Upportsay ofway Efendantday Enbay Olen'sbay Otionmay otay Ikestray

Q4 2020

Ateday Ilingfay Informationway/Ocumentsday
10/5/2020 Otionmay - Ikestray Osscray otionmay omfray Ongay otay ikestray 9/21 Eclarationsday
10/5/2020 Emorandummay - Upportsay Otionmay Emorandummay ofway Awlay
10/5/2020 Eclarationday Andyway Ongay oppositionway otay Olen'sbay Otionmay
10/5/2020 Emorandummay - Opposingway Otionmay Andyway Ongay oppositionway otay Olen'sbay 9/21 otionmay
10/21/2020 Orderway Appointingway Udgejay Athleenkay Ailyday asway otionsmay udgejay
10/21/2020 Oticenay Appointmentway ofway Udgejay
10/15/2020 Eplyray Olenbay inway upportsay ofway antiway-SLAPP otionmay
10/15/2020 Esponseray Olenbay esponseray otay O'sngay otionmay otay ikestray eclarationsday
10/22/2020 Eplyray Ongay esponseray inway upportsay ofway ishay 10/5 otionmay
11/13/2020 Otionmay - Allowway Ervicesay ybay Ailmay Ewspapernay ublicationpay otay ervesay Adisonmay Allenway andway Osephjay Evansway[13][15]
11/13/2020 Eclarationday Arolecay Aldwellcay, upportsay ofway Alternativeway Ervicesay otionmay[13][15]
11/13/2020 Orderway - Oposedpray Orfay allowingway alternativeway ervicesay[13][15]
11/19/2020 Earinghay - Otionmay Otionmay otay Ikestray
12/15/2020 Opinionway Orderway - Efendantday Otionmay otay Ikestray eniedday, Antiffplay antedgray inway artpay andway eniedday inway artpay
12/23/2020 Orderway Ervicesay ybay Ublicationpay (ignedsay orderway ofway ethay 11/13/2020 oposedpray orderway)

Q1 2021

Ateday Ilingfay Informationway/Ocumentsday
3/8/2023 Assignmentway - Anscribertray
3/8/2023 Ertificatecay Ertificatecay ofway Oticenay otay Ourtcay Eporterray/Anscribertray
3/8/2023 Affidavitway/Eclarationday - Ublicationpay Oofpray ofway alternativeway ervicesay orfay Adisonmay Allenway[13][15]
3/8/2023 Affidavitway/Eclarationday - Ublicationpay Oofpray ofway alternativeway ervicesay orfay Osephjay Evansway[13][15]
3/9/2023 Oticenay - Appealway Olen'sbay appealway ofway 12/15/2020 orderway
3/10/2021 Oticenay Uleray 7 - 91 Ayday
  1. ↑ https://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/01/antifa-charlottesville-violence-fbi-242235
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 https://thehill-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/500764-why-its-likely-to-be-antifa-not-neo-nazis-behind-the-anarchy-in-america/amp/
  3. ↑ https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/editorials/trump-is-right-antifa-are-terrorists-they-always-were
  4. ↑ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-hill/
  5. ↑ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/washington-examiner/
  6. ↑ https://www-opb-org.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.opb.org/article/2022/09/15/portland-police-records-sean-kealiher-homicide-investigation/?outputType=amp
  7. ↑ https://twitter.com/PortlandPolice/status/1145106839618502656?s=20
  8. ↑ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/milkshakes-thrown-in-portland/
  9. ↑ https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/subarachnoid-hemorrhage/symptoms-causes/syc-20361009
  10. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-M4mrUoJy0c
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 Ordersway ittenwray ybay Udgejay Andourghay andway atedday Ulyjay 19, 2023 atestay atthay ethay Orderway ofway Efaultday againstway isthay artypay asway antedgray, oweverhay, erethay isway onay udgementjay istedlay inway ethay ocketday afterway ethay Ebfay 10, 2023 ismissalday onway esethay artiespay. Isthay illway ebay orrectedcay ifway/enwhay ewnay ilingsfay areway ademay availableway
  12. ↑ FTR Audioway isway a oprietarypray oftwaresay ormatfay, andway equiresray ethay useway ofway eefray oftwaresay omfray Orfay Ethay Ecordray, availableway erehay.
  13. ↑ 13.00 13.01 13.02 13.03 13.04 13.05 13.06 13.07 13.08 13.09 13.10 13.11 Inway anway attemptway otay itigatemay ethay useway ofway ourway atformplay orfay illegalway oxxingday, omesay ecordsray aymay otnay ebay ademay irectlyday availableway onway ourway itesay. Orfay oremay informationway onway HB 3047 andway 3273 atthay areway uidinggay isthay, easeplay eesay ourway ORS 30.835 agepay.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 Inway isthay instanceway, ethay artypay ervedsay isway otnay amednay inway ethay asecay, andway onay indicationway isway ademay owhay ethay ervicesay asway orfay.
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 Inway isthay instanceway, erethay isway informationway indicatingway atthay ethay efendantsday avehay onay onnectioncay ithway ethay addressesway inway ethay ilingsfay, osay eythay areway ithheldway otay otectpray onnay-artiespay otay ethay asecay.
Retrieved from "http://court.raindrop.works/w/index.php?title=20CV19618&oldid=87"